diff --git a/AGENTS.md b/AGENTS.md index d27ba30..b3dd78f 100644 --- a/AGENTS.md +++ b/AGENTS.md @@ -86,7 +86,8 @@ paragraph-level alternation: Chinese, blank, English, blank). ### Deliverables - `bilingual.dj` — extracted from DOCX (interleaved) -- `edit-suggestions.dj` — mechanical/issues found in the manuscript +- `edit-suggestions.dj` — mechanical/manuscript-level issues +- `translation-findings.dj` — translation quality issues (always produced) ### Extraction @@ -110,22 +111,23 @@ Only flag objective/manuscript-level issues: - **Capitalization typos** — `Philosopher Nietzsche` → `philosopher Nietzsche` - **Stray/unusual characters** in either language -### What NOT to flag +Do NOT flag translation quality issues here — those go to `translation-findings.dj`: -Do NOT flag translation quality issues — the English is authoritative manuscript text: - -- Terminology choices (e.g. "delusional dreams" for 颠倒梦想) -- Translation style, calques, fluency preferences +- Terminology choices, translation style, calques, fluency - Djot formatting conventions (em-dashes, italics) - Word order, added concepts, degree weakening -These belong to the **translation** workflow, not proofread. +### Translation review (translation-findings.dj) -### Separate translation-quality findings +Always produced. Load `translation-review` skill after extraction, scan for: -If the user explicitly asks for a translation review of a proofread article, -write findings to `translation-findings.dj` (separate from `edit-suggestions.dj`). -Load the `translation-review` skill and follow its Workflow B. +- **Terminology** — key Buddhist terms rendered correctly +- **Content omission** — specific examples/explanations dropped +- **Added concepts** — words not in source (e.g. "creator" for 主宰) +- **Degree shifts** — 一切 → "many", weakening of claims +- **Terminology dilution** — technical terms rendered as literary paraphrase +- **Double renderings** — multiple translations of the same term side by side +- **Word order** — reversed logical sequence (e.g. 内圣外王) ---